Saturday, March 10, 2012

The Women of 1975: Diana Ross

Diana Ross in “Mahogany”

Grade: ***

Already an icon of vinyl and screen, Oscar-nominated success Diana Ross migrated from “Lady Sings the Blues” to another story of a troubled woman in a high-profile profession. Berry Gordy cast her in “Mahogany,” a tale of an aspiring fashion designer who gets entrenched in the world of Italian models and temperamental photographers. The film proved a hit for Ross, but the critics didn’t buy it, unsurprising given that the film plays out as a 70s-era soapy melodrama, and has more parallels to Christina Aguilera’s “Burlesque” than just the pop-star-plays-aspirational-protégé premise.

Ross herself is good in the scenes where the film attempts to emulate the vastly superior “Claudine” from the previous year, geared towards Black social commentary and eventually intent on blaming the world of white fashionistas for turning our heroine into a selfish diva. She often sidesteps the badly-written elements of her character designed to inject dramatic effect into a film without legitimately interesting issues of conflict, and is far better than "Mahogany" itself deserves, deploying Tracy’s inherent independence as both a source of charm and a jarring defence mechanism, lending credence to her character’s many erratic eruptions of frustration and self-righteousness. While not a classic tour-de-force, if you’re looking for performances which significantly benefit their film, look no further than Ross, who, on this display, warranted a lengthier filmography than the one she has now.


Candice Frederick said...

i actually really love this film, until the last few minutes when she's forced to give everything up. i thought anthony perkins was also exceptional in this. the beautiful fashion scenes were also radiant. i really liked it. definitely a classic movie.

Calum Reed said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Calum Reed said...

I enjoyed the film, but it's really very flimsy as a dramatic piece. I thought Perkins was terrible too, and I normally love him!

Agreed on the fashion scenes. It really should have gotten a nomination for Costume Design.